Case Story: Convincing the Judge to Reduce our Client’s Felonies to Misdemeanors
Our client drove after drinking too much, crashed his car, and severely hurt his passengers and himself. The state charged him with multiple felonies, but we thought they should be misdemeanors. After a contested sentencing hearing, the judge agreed with us and gave our client a much-deserved second chance.
DISCLAIMER:
CASE RESULTS DEPEND ON A VARIETY OF FACTORS UNIQUE TO EACH CASE. CASE RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE OR PREDICT A SIMILAR RESULT IN ANY FUTURE CASE.
Second chances are a funny thing.
For those who made the mistake, a second chance is always warranted. But for the mistake’s recipient, it’s not so black-and-white.
In other words, it’s easy to want a second chance, but much more difficult to give a second chance.
And it makes sense.
The perpetrator wants to prove that this isn’t who they are. That this was a one-off, not indicative of their true character. And the victim, by contrast, isn’t really interested in hearing it. All they usually care about is that they’ve been wronged and they want the perpetrator to pay.
That’s what this case is about.
Our client did an objectively bad thing: he drank and drove, crashed his car, and severely hurt himself and his friends. And while that’s a huge part of the story, it’s not the whole story. Which is what we told the prosecutor. But she wouldn’t listen.
So we took our argument to the judge and successfully made the case that our client deserved to be punished, but not forever in the form of a felony.
Here’s how we did it.
The Offense
Our client was a college senior at NDSU. At the end of spring break, he went over to a friend’s place one night to attend a house party. Nothing out of the ordinary. Normal college stuff.
Along with his friends, our client drank several beers throughout the night. At some point, he drove to go get a female friend who lived a few blocks away. Having drunk as much as he had, this was a poor decision.
But he did it anyway.
He went and got his female friend and came back to the party. When he arrived, a group of friends who had been at the party were standing outside in the front yard.
Our client asked what they were up to and someone mentioned wanting to leave the party to go “booze cruising.” Booze cruising, for those unfamiliar, is a group of people getting into a car, driving out into the country, and drinking while cruising around on low-traffic backroads.
Not a wise decision, but if we are being honest with our Midwest selves, likely something many of us did in our youth. Since our client was already in his car, having just picked up his female friend, he offered to be the booze cruise driver.
Another bad choice.
Despite knowing that our client had been drinking with them all night, the passengers all got in the car and agreed to go on the booze cruise.
The group drove north of NDSU into the country. Once they got on backroads, our client made the final bad choice of the night: he veered off the road and into a farm field to “chase” a herd of deer a passenger had spotted from the road.
After accelerating to drive close to the deer, our client tried to get out of the farm field and back onto the road. Likely because he had been drinking, our client was unsuccessful in his attempt, missing the approach connecting the farm field and the road and instead driving the car directly into the ditch.
The crash caused the car to flip and our client and passengers to get severely injured. One passenger even needed to be life-flighted to a hospital.
When police arrived, our client admitted to driving after drinking and he was charged with four felony offenses related to the crash.
The Negotiation
After hiring our firm, we did an analysis of the case and realized pretty quickly it was going to be what we call a “mitigation case” — a case where we admit guilt but bring forth mitigating factors to convince the judge to have mercy on our client.
And to that end, we believed we had lots of factors to work with.
We took that mitigating evidence to the prosecuting attorney and made a single, simple request: we would abide by any terms the state wanted if the prosecutor agreed to drop the felonies to misdemeanors.
The rationale was simple—our client was about to graduate from NDSU with a degree in engineering and he was afraid that having felony convictions on his record would make it so that he could never get a job in his chosen field again.
A lifetime scarlet letter for a one-time mistake.
Unfortunately, the prosecutor would not agree to our proposal. So we were left to play the one chip we had left: plead guilty and ask the judge to reduce the felonies to misdemeanors.
A risky gambit, no doubt.
The Sentencing
The reason the gambit was risky was that Minnesota law sets a high bar to reduce a felony down to a misdemeanor.
It doesn’t happen often. It’s difficult to get. And the burden is on the defendant to justify why he is deserving.
So we went to work.
First, we collected letters from our client’s friends, family, and even from one of the passengers in the car the night of the crash They wrote about our client, who he was, and how his conduct that night was not indicative of who he was as a person.
Second, our client wrote letters to both the judge and the most injured passenger. The letters were honest and heartfelt. They did not make excuses. They simply apologized for his bad choices that night and asked that one day they forgive him.
Third, we wrote a long sentencing memo explaining all the reasons why we believed our client deserved a second chance. We weaved in references to all the letters written for our client, all our client’s accomplishments, and all the other factors that pointed in favor of giving him a second chance.
Finally, we decision to have our client testify at the sentencing hearing. In our firm’s history, we had never done this before. And the reason was obvious: by getting on the stand, our client was opening himself up to cross-examination by the state.
A bad cross-examination could make us lose all the goodwill we had earned from our other efforts.
Knowing this, we fully prepared our client for his testimony and cross-examination. And he knocked it out of the park. He was honest and kind and warm, and most of all, apologetic and contrite.
He cried on the stand and begged the families of the passengers who were in court for forgiveness. It was one of the most moving moments our firm has ever experienced in the sentencing context.
The testimony is what shifted everything. It was obvious.
The judge sided with us, reduced our client’s felonies to misdemeanors, and gave him the second chance that he had earned and that he deserved.
The Takeaway
Wins in this job come in all shapes and sizes.
This win was not a not-guilty verdict. Our client knew he had committed the offenses he was charged with.
But the state wanted too much punishment for what happened.
And we told them that. They just wouldn’t listen.
This case is a good lesson in not overplaying your hand, mixed with having a client who truly deserved a second chance.
And through his hard work and ours, he got one.
Additional Case Stories
-

Winning a Federal Drug Case
We got 65 pounds of drugs suppressed and saved our client nearly two decades in prison. It was one of the largest amounts of drugs suppressed in recent North Dakota history.
-

Preventing An Unjust Fraud Conviction
When our client came to us, she was charged with felony fraud and facing years in prison. All because she was the victim of a hacker. We worked hard to make sure this unjust charge got dismissed so her future could remain intact.
-

Winning the First Federal Illegal Reentry Case of Its kind
We were one of the first law firms in the country to take a Supreme Court immigration ruling and apply it to a criminal conviction – and win.

